CINCINNATI — College athletics has rarely been more confusing.
Between NIL, the transfer portal, revenue sharing and seemingly endless court rulings, simply determining who is eligible to play has become almost as difficult as coaching the games themselves.
That brings us to the NCAA's new "five-for-five" eligibility rule and why Cincinnati fans should be paying close attention.
At the center of the discussion is former Utah State standout MJ Collins. When Jerrod Calhoun accepted Cincinnati's head coaching position, it seemed only natural that several of his former players would follow him to Clifton. Collins was one of the biggest names connected to the Bearcats after averaging 17.5 points per game and earning All-Mountain West Second Team honors last season.
The problem isn't whether Collins wants to play at Cincinnati. It's whether the NCAA will allow him to.
The five-for-five rule was designed to give student-athletes five seasons of competition within a five-year window, replacing the patchwork of redshirts, waivers and hardship exceptions that had evolved over the years. But when the rule was implemented, athletes from the high school Class of 2022 were excluded, triggering multiple legal challenges across the country.
Collins is one of the players caught in that uncertainty.
As of late August, Cincinnati remains hopeful that he'll eventually become eligible, but no final decision has been reached. The program has continued preparing as though it could have to begin the season without him while leaving roster flexibility if the courts ultimately rule in his favor.
That's the right approach. The worst thing a coaching staff can do is build a season around something it doesn't control.
If Collins is cleared, the Bearcats add one of the most accomplished scorers in college basketball and a player who already understands Calhoun's system. If he isn't, Cincinnati still believes it has assembled a roster capable of competing in the Big 12.
However, neither outcome changes the work taking place inside Fifth Third Arena. Practices continue. Chemistry continues to develop. Preparations for the season continue.
Eventually, the legal process will catch up.
Until then, the Bearcats can only do what every other program caught in college athletics' ever-changing landscape is doing.
Wait.
And hope.









