COLUMBUS — Where to even begin?
I suppose I’ll start by saying that I’m just as stunned as everyone else by what has happened to this Ohio State football team over the last few weeks. To quote the prologue from P.T. Anderson’s masterpiece, Magnolia, “This cannot be one of those things. This, please, cannot be that.”
Yet, it is.
I have plenty to say, but I’ve struggled to find a central thesis that explains what has gone wrong. Maybe there isn’t one. Maybe this really is a series of unfortunate events, a perfect storm, if you will. And while I believe that’s true in many ways, I also think something bigger is happening.
For all the supposed star power on Ohio State’s roster, outside of Jeremiah Smith, nobody has played like a star. At 6–3, there’s nothing glamorous about this team, but more importantly, there’s nothing gritty about it either. And that’s a problem, though I believe it’s a symptom of a larger issue.
Before getting into that, however, there are a couple of things worth addressing.
First, very few teams can withstand losing their starting quarterback. There are exceptions, of course, as Buckeye fans know all too well (see: Cardale Jones). But football is a quarterback-driven sport, and losing your starter can, and often does, derail an entire season. Once Julian Sayin went down, Ohio State faced an incredibly difficult uphill battle. Expecting a true freshman to step in and lead the Buckeyes to a national championship is flatly unrealistic.
And what about Luke Fahey? The kid has given his all, but he looks exactly like what he is: a three-star true freshman trying to play quarterback at Ohio State. Frankly, it makes me wonder how bad Tavien St. Clair must be if he allowed a three-star freshman to come in and take his job. I can’t imagine St. Clair staying in Columbus after this season, and I wouldn’t blame him. Fahey deserves credit for his effort, but he doesn't throw a consistent spiral, and his accuracy is an issue. I’m sure he’ll improve, but I’m not sure why he’s starting right now. He simply isn't ready, and that’s not a knock on him.
Second, when a starting quarterback goes down, the teams that survive are usually the ones that elevate their play everywhere else. The offensive line blocks better, the defense makes more stops, and special teams execute. The entire roster recognizes that more is being asked of everyone, and the players respond by giving the new quarterback the support he needs.
That clearly isn't happening in Columbus, and I believe that's another symptom of the larger problem.
Before going any further, though, let me address something else: Ryan Day isn't getting fired.
Like many of you, I've seen the headlines suggesting otherwise across various media outlets. As a journalist, let me call those headlines exactly what they are: clickbait lies right to your face in the name of profit. Full stop. If you've read our editorial principles, you know that kind of journalism is antithetical to everything we do here. The journalists and publications that conduct business that way should be ignored, shunned, and called out for the greedy liars they are.
And while we're at it, Matt Patricia and Ryan Day haven't suddenly become morons who don't know how to coach. The problems at Ohio State have very little to do with coaching, though the staff certainly deserves some blame. The much bigger issue is the players on the field.
In this modern era of NIL and the transfer portal, Ohio State welcomed 51 newcomers to its roster. Fifty-one new players, or, as I see it, fifty-one hired mercenaries. They aren't Buckeyes. They're hired guns.
And therein lies the real problem.
I'm not suggesting these are bad people or that any of them arrived with bad intent. But I don't believe they fully understand where they are or what's expected of them. More importantly, they haven't figured out how to become a team instead of a collection of hired hands.
The coaching staff deserves criticism for recruiting the wrong group of players and then failing to get them to play like Buckeyes. But ultimately, it's the players who have to figure things out and execute on the field. The X's and O's are fine. They have been since Day arrived. The problem is that the Jimmies and the Joes are playing as individuals instead of a single unit.
In other words, they're playing like mercenaries.
Hopefully, the next group is better equipped and more willing to embrace what it means to play for Ohio State. Beyond that, I hope Congress eventually passes legislation that brings some order to the Wild West of college football. The current system desperately needs stability, especially when it comes to building and retaining a roster.
None of this means a group of transfers can't come together and become a cohesive team. Indiana has already shown that it's possible, although its group of hired hands this year isn't nearly as good as last year's. Never has the idea that every season brings an entirely different team been more apparent than it is now.
And who knows? Maybe the loss to Oregon will finally bring the Buckeyes together. Maybe the collective light bulb will come on, and they'll finish the season strong. It could happen, but I wouldn't bet on it.
What happens next will be fascinating because I genuinely have no idea how this team is going to respond. Along with all the "Fire Ryan Day" nonsense, there's also been plenty of talk about Jeremiah Smith's future and how much longer he'll play this season. For all I know, Day may have told him today to start preparing for the draft. I have no idea, and neither does anyone outside those conversations.
We'll have to wait and see how all of that plays out. In fact, we'll have to wait and see how any of this plays out.
This is uncharted territory for all of us, and I'm just as shocked as you are.









