COLUMBUS — Ohio State head coach Ryan Day isn't ready to make a change at quarterback. Despite consecutive losses to USC and Oregon, Day confirmed Tuesday that freshman Luke Fahey will remain the starter when the Buckeyes host Northwestern on Saturday.
That decision means former five-star recruit Tavien St. Clair will spend another week as the backup, even as questions continue about Fahey's ability to lead Ohio State's passing attack.
"Luke is going to be our quarterback this week, and Tavien's one snap away," Day told reporters Tuesday.
Day added that the coaching staff would make a change if it believed St. Clair gave Ohio State the best chance to win, but said the team hasn't reached that point. Nor did Day clarify what that point would look like.
Fahey, a three-star recruit from California, took over after Julian Sayin suffered an elbow injury against Indiana. The Buckeyes have since lost 30-18 at USC and 41-28 at home against Oregon, dropping to 6-3 and leaving their College Football Playoff hopes in serious trouble.
On paper, Fahey's performance against Oregon looks okay. He completed 36 of 50 passes for 360 yards, two touchdowns, and an interception, setting Ohio State's single-game passing record for a true freshman. However, those numbers don't tell the entire story.
Ohio State led Oregon 14-0 before the Ducks scored 38 unanswered points. Fahey struggled to move the offense during much of that stretch, frequently relying on short throws and checkdowns. Both of his touchdown passes came in the fourth quarter after Oregon had built a commanding lead. Which is to say, the vast majority of his numbers came during garbage time when USC was playing basically a prevent defense, and the only plays that were made against that defense were about 1,001 check-downs to running backs while the rest of the defense was farther downfield. In other words, the numbers are meaningless.
Those struggles raise questions about whether Fahey can consistently challenge defenses downfield, or on any portion of the field. He has shown he can complete passes, but Ohio State needs more from its passing attack than short completions, especially when opponents begin taking away the running game.
The decision to keep him in the lineup is even more interesting with St. Clair waiting behind him. St. Clair arrived as one of the nation's top quarterback recruits, while Fahey was rated the No. 35 quarterback in the 2026 recruiting class. Recruiting rankings don't determine who should start, but they make Day's continued preference for Fahey worth examining, if not bewildering.
Of course, the quarterback hasn't been Ohio State's only problem. The Buckeyes rushed for just 53 yards against Oregon, and their defense allowed 41 points. Changing quarterbacks won't fix those issues, and St. Clair hasn't established that he would perform better.
Still, Ohio State has lost both games since Fahey became the starter, and the offense hasn't been even mediocre.
Day clearly believes Fahey gives the Buckeyes their best chance to win right now. Saturday against Northwestern offers another opportunity to prove that judgment correct, but with Nebraska and Michigan still on the schedule, Ohio State can't afford to spend much longer searching for answers at quarterback.









