CLEVELAND — Cleveland Browns head coach Todd Monken has a difficult decision ahead of Sunday's matchup against the Houston Texans. Deshaun Watson has cleared concussion protocol and is available to return, but Shedeur Sanders made a strong case for another start with his performance against New Orleans.
Sanders completed 19 of 31 passes for 297 yards and two touchdowns without an interception in Sunday's 23-22 overtime loss to the Saints. It wasn't a perfect performance, but he gave Cleveland's offense a spark when it needed one and nearly led the Browns to victory.
His first three quarters were uneven, which is seemingly no different than what the Browns look like with Watson running the show. Cleveland managed just six points, and Sanders struggled at times against the Saints' pass rush. However, he improved as the game went on, especially when the Browns began taking more chances downfield.
With Cleveland trailing 9-6 in the fourth quarter, Sanders connected with KC Concepcion on a 64-yard touchdown pass that gave the Browns their first touchdown of the afternoon. Later, after New Orleans regained the lead, Sanders helped move Cleveland into position for Andre Szmyt's 51-yard field goal that forced overtime.
His biggest throw came in the extra period, when he found Harold Fannin Jr. for a 39-yard touchdown that brought Cleveland within one point. The Browns elected to go for two and the victory, but the conversion failed, leaving Sanders and his teammates with a frustrating loss.
Despite the outcome, Sanders showed something Cleveland has been looking for offensively. He was willing to attack downfield, trusted his receivers to make plays, and didn't throw an interception. Those are encouraging signs for a quarterback making his first start of the season.
Watson's return complicates the decision. He started Cleveland's first eight games and helped the team reach a 5-3 record before entering concussion protocol following the November 1 loss to Pittsburgh. Monken now has to decide whether to return to the quarterback who guided the Browns through the first half of the season or give Sanders another opportunity.
The coach hasn't committed to either player. Speaking Monday, Monken said he wanted to review the Saints game with his offensive staff before making a decision. His priority remains putting the players on the field who give Cleveland the best chance to win, which seems to suggest he'll lean toward Watson, given his experience.
But objectively looking at the situation is the right approach, and Sanders deserves serious consideration. One strong performance doesn't automatically make him Cleveland's best quarterback, just as one loss shouldn't erase what he accomplished Sunday. Watson's experience and familiarity with the offense does matter, but so does the production Sanders delivered when given his opportunity, and moreover whether it helps the Browns long-term.
The Browns are 5-4 and still have plenty to play for. Sunday's matchup with Houston is important, and Monken can't afford to make the decision based on anything other than which quarterback gives Cleveland the better chance to win.
Sanders has earned another start. Whether Monken agrees may be one of the most important decisions he makes this season.









